DETROIT – With the start of school around the corner, many districts have released their plans regarding mask policies.
Some Metro Detroit school districts claim to be consistent with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and state guidelines, but don’t appear to be.
Related: Michigan releases COVID guidance for upcoming school year, urges universal masking
“While the state is is making recommendations and not mandates, the actual recommendation is that schools have universal masking and that means all students, all teachers, all staff wear masks in the school,” said Dr. Joneigh Khaldun. “That would actually be following the CDC recommendations.”
Khaldun, Michigan’s chief medical executive, said optional mask policies are not consistent with the guidelines of the CDC or the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services.
“If everyone in that school is not wearing a mask, then that is not following the CDC recommendation,” Khaldun said. “If one person has COVID and they’re not wearing a mask -- even though it’s really good for the other person to wear a mask -- it’s still easier for the virus to be transmitted.”
Data: Michigan’s vulnerability ‘high’ as COVID sweeps across US again
Khaldun is also a mother to three school age children.
“My children certainly will be wearing masks when they go back to school. We’ve already talked about it, just to keep keep them safe, so I think that’s the right thing to do,” Khaldun said. “Of course, I’m concerned because I do have one child who’s too young to be vaccinated and I think wearing masks is how we’re going to keep our children safe, and in school in-person learning which is so important.”
So if masks are so critical to keeping students safe and schools open, why hasn’t the state mandated them?
“There’s so many things that go into government decisions. I know the Governor has a tough job, but again we are strongly recommending universal masking in our schools,” Khaldun said. “That’s the right thing to do.”
More: Coronavirus news
“The health, safety, and welfare of students and staff is of the utmost importance to Plymouth-Canton Community Schools. To that end the District has followed all health and safety mandates regarding COVID-19.
When there are not COVID-19 mandates, but rather recommendations, the District will review its responsibilities to educate all of our 17,000 students based on what is best for our students and staff while continuously monitoring transmission data in our schools and communities. We may modify our requirements based on this data and how to best educate our students.
As described in our current 2021-22 Mitigation Guidelines, P-CCS is strongly recommending universal mask wearing for all staff and students while indoors (regardless of vaccination status) at every level. If P-CCS is expected to require universal mask wearing in all schools, we await this directive in the form of a mandate from the MDHSS in order to provide more clarity for local school districts. The District will comply with any mandates and public health orders as we have consistently done throughout this pandemic.”
Plymouth-Canton Community Schools superintendent Monica L. Merritt