DETROIT – Andrew Middlebrooks is charged with running a Ponzi scheme that eventually imploded, losing investors millions of dollars along the way.
He promised huge gains, which went along with the considerable promise he showed becoming the first African American hedge fund manager in Michigan as a young man.
It’s looking like he’s come to a plea agreement with the federal government for defrauding the people who put their trust in him.
Middlebrooks made headlines as a child prodigy, learning about the stock market from his father. He later developed his own specialized research program to analyze stocks and funds in real-time and opened his fund called EIA All Weather Alpha Fund Partners in Detroit and later moved to Texas.
He got off to an award-winning start in 2017, but things didn’t take long to go south. On Wednesday (Oct. 12), the U.S. Attorney’s Office put out the information saying, “From the beginning of the scheme, Middlebrooks’ (sic) investments failed to produce the returns investors anticipated resulting in catastrophic losses. Rather than admitting that EIA’s fund was losing money, Middlebrooks, with intent to defraud, continued to solicit money and lied to investors about EIA’s investment performance.”
Middlebrooks assured the highly wealthy individuals he spoke with his new technology could get them massive returns. Court documents said those returns never materialized: “Middlebrooks reported positive returns of 135.74% in 2020 when he knew EIA had incurred losses of over $13 million. Middlebrooks took money from the fund for living expenses and transferred money from the fund to his wife’s business.”
Then it devolved into a Ponzi scheme.
“Middlebrooks paid over $9 million back to investors claiming the money represented returned generated through EIA trades. In fact, these payments came from new investor money. Losses to at least 100 investors exceeded $27 million.”
The case started back in May when the Federal Securities and Exchange Commission shut down EIA and then handed the case over to the U.S. Attorney.
Here is a statement from Middlebrooks’ attorney:
This matter is far from the usual fraud case in many respects. The most important distinction being that Andrew Middlebrooks was legitimately attempting to make money for those who invested in his private hedge fund, including his parents and other members of his own family. The typical fraud defendant intends to do the opposite, that is, separate people from their money. The mistake Andrew and others working with him made was that, when some of the investments began to lose money, instead of admitting that fact, Andrew tried to right the ship with riskier investments that did not pan out, resulting in substantial losses to the fund. His crime was in concealing those losses in order to buy himself and his partners more time to make his fund profitable.
In April of this year, Andrew admitted to himself that he could not fix the situation and self-reported the fund’s losses and his concealment of those losses to the United States Attorney’s Office in Detroit. Self-reporting is almost unheard of in fraud cases. Andrew has been fully cooperative in the federal investigation and remains so. Unlike defendants such as Bernie Madoff, who never made real investments for his fraud victims and lived lavishly off stolen money, Andrew genuinely believed he could make his family and other investors money based on his education and experience in market investing. Andrew also invested and lost all of his own money and did not profit from his fund. Andrew willingly signed over all of his remaining assets to the government, which amounted to only a single automobile.
R. Michael Bullotta, Counsel for Andrew Middlebrooks