DETROIT – It was a deal that was kept tightly under wraps. If approved, it would create the largest hospital system in the state of Michigan.
Read: Beaumont Health, Spectrum Health announce intent to merge
The merger would bring together both sides of Michigan with Grand Rapids’ Spectrum Health and Southfield’s Beaumont Health.
“It’s really about the synergies of our organizations coming together,” said Beaumont Health board chair Julie Fream. “This is for Michigan and by Michigan. We have equal governance and a shared opportunity to work together on our complimentary strengths.”
It’s the third big merger attempt for Beaumont Health under CEO John Fox and the second within a year. Beaumont Health’s last merger attempt was with Wisconsin-based Advocate Aurora. The partnership was called off in October 2020 after staff, donors and lawmakers said it could negatively impact patient care.
Fox will reportedly leave the organization following the once the transition is over.
Rep. Andy Levin, who criticized the potential Advocate Aurora merger, said he was cautiously optimistic regarding the new potential union. He released the following statement Thursday:
“As our communities and health systems continue to recover from what we hope is a once-in-a-century pandemic, I will evaluate this proposed merger with great care. I am committed to preventing spikes in health care costs and worse patient outcomes, as evidence indicates can happen following mergers. I will not accept inferior care for my constituents in the name of consolidation of competition or growth of revenue.
I am cautiously optimistic about certain aspects of this new partnership. Spectrum Health appears to have fewer labor complaints against their management. I hope the leadership of the proposed new entity takes seriously their obligations to their workers including ensuring they are protected in the workplace and respecting their freedom to form a union and bargain collectively if they choose.
The departure of Beaumont CEO John Fox and the end to the speculation that Beaumont will be acquired by a larger, out-of-state entity is also welcome news. I look forward to meeting Tina Freese Decker, working to understand the proposed broader leadership structure and connecting with those involved in order to make sure that my constituents have access to the highest quality care, lower costs and better workplaces.”
Rep. Andy Levin (MI-09)
There are concerns about what it could mean for the cost and quality of care.
“I don’t see a lot of potential benefits for consumers in the state,” said Dr. Richard Hirth, professor of hospital policy at University of Michigan. “It may not be quite as much of a threat to prices as if they did have that overlapping footprint, but I think there’s still a possibility that prices could go up.”
When it comes to just how much the merger is worth, it’s difficult to pin down. Spectrum Health CEO Tina Freese Decker dodged multiple questions regarding the price. Both companies bring in billions in revenue and Spectrum operates Priority Health, the third largest insurance company of its kind in the United States.
The agreement between the two health systems needs to be approved by the state and likely federal regulators.